Updated

What is a ratchet mortgage?

A ratchet mortgage is a home loan whose interest rate can reset lower when market rates fall but never rises. It’s also called a one-way ARM: like an adjustable-rate mortgage, its rate can follow market rates down, but unlike one, it can’t follow them back up.

Who came up with the ratchet mortgage?

Andrew Kalotay and Bert Ely proposed the ratchet mortgage. Kalotay has described it as a “one-way ARM” (Kalotay, “The Case for the Ratchet Mortgage,” Mortgage Contract Design Conference, 2015).

How is a ratchet mortgage different from an ARM?

An ARM’s rate can rise as well as fall, while a ratchet mortgage’s rate can only fall. After its initial fixed period, an ARM’s rate adjusts up or down with its index, within its caps. A ratchet mortgage’s rate resets lower when market rates fall and stays where it is when they rise. See the CFPB’s explainer, What is the difference between a fixed-rate and adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) loan?

Downward-only vs. capped at the starting rate

There are two versions of the idea: a rate that only ever moves down, and a rate that moves with the market but never above where it started. The CFPB’s 2022 request for information on mortgage refinances and forbearances describes both: a mortgage whose rate automatically decreases with market rates but never increases, as distinct from a variation whose rate moves with the market but never rises above its original rate (CFPB, request for information on mortgage refinances and forbearances, Docket No. CFPB-2022-0059). In the capped version, a rate that has fallen can rise again, up to the original rate. In the downward-only version, it can’t. Marian is the downward-only kind: its rate never goes up.

What’s the trade-off?

The right to a lower rate later is priced into the starting rate, so you start higher than a comparable standard fixed-rate loan. The feature pays off only if market rates fall enough during the loan; if they never fall meaningfully, it buys nothing. In a design with a floor, such as Marian’s, resets stop at that floor.

That makes one number a useful way to judge any ratchet or down-only loan: how much higher its starting rate is than a standard fixed-rate loan’s.

Is anyone offering a ratchet mortgage?

Marian is a planned down-only mortgage built on this idea, but it is pre-launch and not lending in any state. After an initial fixed period, when market rates fall by a defined amount, Marian’s rate resets lower automatically, down to a floor. Read what a down-only mortgage is and how it compares with refinancing and other options.

Sources